Did you see the new Who ?

[ctc]

>The ending made the whole episode kind of pointless.

Which was kind of the point. To be pointless. So, that was the point.

....er....

I thought the episode was okay; but I was kinda expecting to find out the deal with the Crooked Man from the previous episode.

Don C.

[Mikey]

Nah she was way prettier than thelma

[tmthor]

Am I crazy ? .... The girl kept reminding me of a young Talia Shire from Rocky

I thought they tried to make her look like a real life Thelma from Scooby Doo

[johnmiic]

The Library, wouldn't that have been the room that the 8th Doctor's console was in? It looked like the only room that I could identify from a previous adventure.

[jwyblejr]

The ending made the whole episode kind of pointless.

[Bruce Banner]

It was great seeing some more of the TARDIS interior.

But yeah, I really wish there's been a little more reference to the classic episodes in there somewhere... maybe a glimpse of some of the old classic control rooms or something.

The Van Baalen brothers were annoying.

Clara is actually pretty interesting to me. I like her character, and the actress.
Really looking forward to finding out the mystery behind her.

[Mikey]

I don't mind Clara (the actress and character) .... I just wish they would let her be a normal companion (as in the classic series) and that's it.

I knew they were doing too good having 2 episodes in a row that I liked

Then the reality of Moffat came back

[pmwasson]

I'm not finding Clara interesting either.

Yeah me either. I thought they were setting it up so that she kept dying and then the actress would play a different version of her each episode. But now I'm just getting kind of bored with her.

I wished the empath from the haunted house episode was the companion. I would like to have seen more of her.

[johnnystorm]

Really expected to get to see more of the Tardis rooms, such as the Cloister room, the other console room, maybe the bedrooms, the kitchen, etc. I also would have hoped to see some momentos of previous adventures, even find out Kamelion was still aboard. We did see the swimming pool & library.
The monsters were a letdown for me.. Not very interesting.
I'm not finding Clara interesting either.

[Mikey]

For me, tonights episode started out good but lost steam by the end.

Wish the monsters were something else.

Also, the end was very cliche.

I give it 1-1/2 stars

[jds1911a1]

I just hope they don't ruin a good thing by doing another over the top season finale related to the companion.

I miss the days when a companion was just a companion and not the savior of the universe EVERY year

Right on brother

[Mikey]

I just hope they don't ruin a good thing by doing another over the top season finale related to the companion.

I miss the days when a companion was just a companion and not the savior of the universe EVERY year

[jds1911a1]

my only complaint was the way Matt pronoiced Metabelis. Matt used a soft vowel sounds me-tab-al-is while Jon always used hard vowles Meh-tah-bee-lis. Moffot is enough of a fan he should have got that right.
An excellent spooky story, rigth there with the Hichcliff era or Ghostlight

[raider5gt]

This weeks Who was ok,I thought the creature was kind of spooky though.

Last weeks episode with the Ice Warrior was the best for me this season.(I have only just caught up with these.) It was nice to see David Warner on screen again.It was funny to see him blasting Ultravox out on his Walkman and then asking if they were split up or not.

[Gorn Captain]

Am I crazy ? .... The girl kept reminding me of a young Talia Shire from Rocky

Well, it's that period in time, so maybe the hair and clothes were similar.