So now that it's over & done, was it worth it? I think so, I really enjoyed the ride and I'd buy it again. And I'm not certain what format the collected edition will be in (tabloid-size has been mentioned by DC), but I think it won't be right anyway, that is it probably worked best in the weekly newspaper format and won't be as good if read in one long sitting as oposed to once a week like it was planned.
My opinions in wrap-up:
BATMAN- pretty art, weak story, the final panels WAY to melodramatic. Would have preferred a super-villain romp with a Silver-Age Joker or Penguin story.
KAMANDI- it doesn't get better than this, was worth the entire price for that single page.
SUPERMAN- see the Batman entry but substitute a Golden-Age Superman vs. Prankster - or an adaption of a Fleischer cartoon?
DEADMAN- nice story, nice art, solid.
GREEN LANTERN- a bit meandering, but also solid throughout.
SUPERGIRL- again, Amanda Conner is just such a good cartoonist, this is top shelf fun.
METAMORPHO- disappointing because it played too cutesy for me with the wink & a nod stuff from Gaimen, but still nice to see Rex in action again, ditto Element Girl. (As an aside to this not related to the comic, I noticed the DC B&B toyline mini-figures out and he is not called Metamorpho on the package, but Rex Mason, Element Man.Anybody know why?)
TEEN TITANS- who cares? It was a poorly done, and I'm not even certain just who or why they were fighting.
ADAM STRANGE- Again, this was a great read, I'd like to see more.
WONDER WOMAN. Two words: Train Wreck.
METAL MEN- Good stuff, really good stuff. DC give us more of THIS. No need to find a "new direction". And get Garcia-Lopez a series, please? How about Superboy or Aquaman or ANYTHING!
SGT. ROCK- Pretty to look at, not much story though when it was all said & done.
FLASH- A lot of people thought this was great, I thought it was a bit confusing, but the art was nice. Not a Grodd fan, I think he's overused. Maybe next time a good ol' fashioned Trickster caper.
DEMON-CATWOMAN- ok, nothing great, nice oddball teaming though.
HAWKMAN- Weird, it was weird. Mostly a non-flying Hawkman who needed Aquaman to bail him out. Way to showcase the guy DC! Maybe next time Aquaman can have an adventure in New Mexico and Hawkman can show up to save him with a Giant Condor.
All in all though, I hope DC does this again. Next time though, a western & a kid or funny animal strip is needed. Sugar & Spike, Fox & Crow...Johnny Thunder or Trigger Twins...the Silver Age Batman..a silver age Wonder Woman...
I don't see that big-names are really necessary for the entire book, so how about a boxing story ala' Joe Palooka starring Wildcat? Or an aviation type Terry & the Pirates story starring Hop Harrigan. A Slam Bradley detective strip would fit nicely, or a romance strip (with Nick Cardy art!)
Get your heroes fighting the classic arch-villains in all the strips.
My opinions in wrap-up:
BATMAN- pretty art, weak story, the final panels WAY to melodramatic. Would have preferred a super-villain romp with a Silver-Age Joker or Penguin story.
KAMANDI- it doesn't get better than this, was worth the entire price for that single page.
SUPERMAN- see the Batman entry but substitute a Golden-Age Superman vs. Prankster - or an adaption of a Fleischer cartoon?
DEADMAN- nice story, nice art, solid.
GREEN LANTERN- a bit meandering, but also solid throughout.
SUPERGIRL- again, Amanda Conner is just such a good cartoonist, this is top shelf fun.
METAMORPHO- disappointing because it played too cutesy for me with the wink & a nod stuff from Gaimen, but still nice to see Rex in action again, ditto Element Girl. (As an aside to this not related to the comic, I noticed the DC B&B toyline mini-figures out and he is not called Metamorpho on the package, but Rex Mason, Element Man.Anybody know why?)
TEEN TITANS- who cares? It was a poorly done, and I'm not even certain just who or why they were fighting.
ADAM STRANGE- Again, this was a great read, I'd like to see more.
WONDER WOMAN. Two words: Train Wreck.
METAL MEN- Good stuff, really good stuff. DC give us more of THIS. No need to find a "new direction". And get Garcia-Lopez a series, please? How about Superboy or Aquaman or ANYTHING!
SGT. ROCK- Pretty to look at, not much story though when it was all said & done.
FLASH- A lot of people thought this was great, I thought it was a bit confusing, but the art was nice. Not a Grodd fan, I think he's overused. Maybe next time a good ol' fashioned Trickster caper.
DEMON-CATWOMAN- ok, nothing great, nice oddball teaming though.
HAWKMAN- Weird, it was weird. Mostly a non-flying Hawkman who needed Aquaman to bail him out. Way to showcase the guy DC! Maybe next time Aquaman can have an adventure in New Mexico and Hawkman can show up to save him with a Giant Condor.
All in all though, I hope DC does this again. Next time though, a western & a kid or funny animal strip is needed. Sugar & Spike, Fox & Crow...Johnny Thunder or Trigger Twins...the Silver Age Batman..a silver age Wonder Woman...
I don't see that big-names are really necessary for the entire book, so how about a boxing story ala' Joe Palooka starring Wildcat? Or an aviation type Terry & the Pirates story starring Hop Harrigan. A Slam Bradley detective strip would fit nicely, or a romance strip (with Nick Cardy art!)
Get your heroes fighting the classic arch-villains in all the strips.
Comment