Brandon Routh no longer under contract for Supes!

[Hector]

I've read the NEXT batch of posts since my last posts and am highly amused
by the diverse and divergent ideas brought forth in such a short stack of
opinions.

Good LUCK plesaing THIS crowd WB!

Don't worry about the WB crowd...they number like 100.

[Hector]

Hey , Hector.......counterpoint this.

Batman is better than Superman because he is easier to cast in a movie.

Seriously, Batman is easier to cast because of the dark nature, a gritty realism that Supes could never have, the fact that a cowl and rubber-armored costume can hide a lot (heck, apparently, it makes sense in Hollywood to even give Bats some nipples).

With Supes, you need a well-built Dude who can pass as Milquetoast Clark Kent, can't be well-known, and must be able to convey an image of the ultimate Boy Scout who could kick yer arse, yet chooses not to, even though he really should (make that believable in any medium).

That's no small order, my friends.

Except for the Batman is better than Supes part...I agree with the rest of your post.

[Hector]

I would hate to see Superman brought back and made "dark" like Batman trying to bring in the new modern audience.

Batman works dark because it's a part of his character going way back... So it's not out of place.
Superman dark would be a joke and a laughing stock.
It would be like bringing back Mr Rogers and trying to make him dark and cutting edge.

If they did want to try something different, I would suggest basing a new Superman movie on Max Fleischer's version -- including the suit.
Set the movie in WW2 ...
Have Superman JUMP but not fly...
That would be interesting

Not bad ideas, Mike.

You are finally starting to make some sense.

[Hector]

There are rumors of a Superman Metropolis TV movie.... TV only (at least that is what I heard)

KEEP TOM ON THE SMALL SCREEN!!!

(With a little sign that says, Do Not Open --- Ever!)

Agreed.

[saildog]

We'll just have to wait and see.... (plenty to keep us all speculating!! )

(Barney Fife voice)

sniff...and that's what it's really all about.

(At least, that's what makes it fun for me.)

[60'schild]

I think it all comes down to the exact definition and extent of "dark"... (especially the latter). If you can make it as "dark" as say Iron Man, fine... but turning Supes into the Dark Knight is WAY too much overkill...

A SERIOUS adventure story (with the "boy scout" angle toned down) would be great but excessively dark would turn off as many, I think (given the character). I want a POWERFUL superman, but not an excessively dark one... (he still has to have a humanity to be Supes while looking like he can be taken seriously)

Rather than a Christopher Reeve vibe, I'd say more of a George Reeves (on Alex Ross steriods both physically and emotionally)... Take equal parts Alex Ross version and Curt Swan version and mix ??

It is really a balancing act ... and whatever you do, it has to blend into the "tone" of future DC films if they EVER hope to make a JLA ....

We'll just have to wait and see.... (plenty to keep us all speculating!! )

[jasonmego1277]

I have heard that they are indeed looking to reboot. They want the film to have a darker tone like the Nolan Batman films. Actually The Shazam film in in development hell because of this too. WB wants it darker and John August wanted it to be Big meets Superman. Taht being said I am surprised that Routh is out of his contract. I was hearing he was locked in no matter what. Well might be a good thing, time will tell.

[huedell]

I've read the NEXT batch of posts since my last posts and am highly amused
by the diverse and divergent ideas brought forth in such a short stack of
opinions.

Good LUCK plesaing THIS crowd WB!

My opinion?

Don't mess with the overall Reeve vibe too much.

Make the Reeve-esque movie the MAJORITY of people WANT to see.

i.e. not III, IV, or SR

Routh/Singer would've succeeeded but they pushed the boundaries too much.

SHORT TRANSLATION:
Make the "new" Superman, much like the Reeve Superman but with
no direct ties to him/his continuity.

[Captain]

just find someone that comes close to Alex Ross's version and you've got it.

http://www.flixens.com/files/hill_superman2.jpg

Puddy from Seinfeld!

[60'schild]

There had been a rumor of the next film being called Superman: Man of Steel. In fact, there is an entry for it on IMDB:

Superman: Man of Steel (2011)

Yes, but no connection with the Metropolis TV movie rumor (which I believe came up before Welling had re-signed for multiple more seasons).

[Ghostwriter71]

There had been a rumor of the next film being called Superman: Man of Steel. In fact, there is an entry for it on IMDB:

Superman: Man of Steel (2011)

[saildog]

Hey , Hector.......counterpoint this.

Batman is better than Superman because he is easier to cast in a movie.

Seriously, Batman is easier to cast because of the dark nature, a gritty realism that Supes could never have, the fact that a cowl and rubber-armored costume can hide a lot (heck, apparently, it makes sense in Hollywood to even give Bats some nipples).

With Supes, you need a well-built Dude who can pass as Milquetoast Clark Kent, can't be well-known, and must be able to convey an image of the ultimate Boy Scout who could kick yer arse, yet chooses not to, even though he really should (make that believable in any medium).

That's no small order, my friends.

[60'schild]

I agree that "dark" is definitely not the way to go, but too light (Brandon Routh) or stumbling Clark isn't either.

I'm looking for something in the middle ...

[Mikey]

I would hate to see Superman brought back and made "dark" like Batman trying to bring in the new modern audience.

Batman works dark because it's a part of his character going way back... So it's not out of place.
Superman dark would be a joke and a laughing stock.
It would be like bringing back Mr Rogers and trying to make him dark and cutting edge.

If they did want to try something different, I would suggest basing a new Superman movie on Max Fleischer's version -- including the suit.
Set the movie in WW2 ...
Have Superman JUMP but not fly...
That would be interesting

[saildog]

I won't begrudge someone watching Smallville, in fact, I have watched it on occasion and sometimes I enjoy it......the chick that plays Lois is smoking hot and I'm a sucker for anything Green Arrow related, but man, oh man, is there ever a reason it is on the WB or the CW.

East is East and West is West, as they say.