I'd have to pick Elton John - some of his 70s work is really incredible. After that - er - not so much to me.
I like Billy Joel, but he's only got about 5 or 6 really stand out pop songs to me. Which is pretty good! It's just that in my mind comparing the two John's work is more influential and interesting overall.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Billy Joel vs Elton John
Collapse
X
-
-
Billy Joel writes his own compositions. Elton John seldom does. Billy wins hands down.Leave a comment:
-
Just personal preference, I'd pick Elton John. I love Billy Joel's music as well but if I were to line up all of the Elton John songs I like vs. Billy Joel songs; Elton wins.Leave a comment:
-
I think Billy Joel would win in a fight. Wait...what was the question?Leave a comment:
-
Billy Joel vs Elton John
Of the two, who is your favorite piano man ?
I have to pick Elton.
Joel is ok, but sometimes his songs really annoy me (see The Longest Time)
I think Elton beats Joel for staying power too.
Who's your fav ?Tags: None


Leave a comment: