Help support the Mego Museum
Help support the Mego Museum

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Favourite John Byrne

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • johnmiic
    Adrift
    • Sep 6, 2002
    • 8427

    #16
    I loved his Captain America. I bought Alpha Flight but didn't relly understand why he wrote it the way he did. I thought he was developing the backstories until issue #12 and after that the book would go into overdrive but it didn't happen. The death of James Hudson was a bold move.

    I was hooked on his FF run. I noticed a change in his style when he started the Negative Zone saga. At the time he was criticized for it looking too muddy. They explained that he was trying out some new markers to draw with. He seemed to get the hang of it tho. Eventually his lines became thicker. I took some art classes and usually to loosen up an artist they make you draw with soft charcoal to get thicker lines.The art looked like that for a time. I think one of his peaks was THING#2 which he inked. The art in that issue is probably the closest he has ever come to bringing the THING to real life.

    I liked his work on the DC mini-series Legends more than on Superman. Maybe it proves he was meant to do Shazam more than Superman. His Shazam is faithful and yet contemporary and fresh. Byrne has stated in interviews that he left Superman because DC got nervous with the changes he was making and said there's Superman continuity and John Byrne's Superman. When you look at it, he was bringing the comic more in line w/the Richard Donner film: Superman I. Byrne heard this and decided he was wasting his time working on Superman so he left.

    He did a very good OMAC miniseries in black and white. I liked his West Coast Avengers, ( he brought back the original Human Torch!). I have his run on She-Hulk, which was good. It was a farce and not serious. His Namor run seemed more like he was bringing DC flavor to Marvel but I like his version of Namor. Namor has wet, slicked back hair. Not the wiers hammerhead do that was so prevelent in the 80's.

    He did a pretty good job on Star Trek's Assignment Earth. I wish he would do more and not limit each story to 1 issue each. His Star Trek Crew is pretty good. I read 3 issues so far. It follows the career of Majel Barrett Rodenberry's character, Number 1.

    Byrne has many FAQ up on his own website, johnbyrnerobotics.com, that are really interesting. He is very strict tho about what you post and the FAQ are intense. They fill you in on a lot of the "why did you do that" moments in his career.

    Comment

    • thunderbolt
      Hi Ernie!!!
      • Feb 15, 2004
      • 34211

      #17
      ^^ Forgot about OMAC, great book.
      You must try to generate happiness within yourself. If you aren't happy in one place, chances are you won't be happy anyplace. -Ernie Banks

      Comment

      • spiderrogue
        new mego-er
        • Feb 3, 2008
        • 0

        #18
        im gonna get shot..but i despise john byrne for ruining spidey in the late 90's with that relaunch crap...arrrgghhhh....but other than that..i did like his xmen stuff..so that is ok....phew..that was a close one...

        Comment

        • Random Axe
          The Voice of Reason
          • Apr 16, 2008
          • 4518

          #19
          A couple of you, myself included, brought up Legends as a Byrne favorite. Anyone know if this was ever collected in a trade? I could always go and get the back issues, but it would be nice to have it all together in one binding.

          Scott
          I almost had a psychic girlfriend but she dumped me before we met.

          If anyone here believes in psychokinesis, please raise my hand.

          Comment

          • Bionic Joe
            Persistent Member
            • Dec 10, 2006
            • 1749

            #20
            Originally posted by Random Axe
            A couple of you, myself included, brought up Legends as a Byrne favorite. Anyone know if this was ever collected in a trade? I could always go and get the back issues, but it would be nice to have it all together in one binding.

            Scott
            I believe it was a long time ago, Might be easier to track down the inv issues

            Comment

            • kingdom warrior
              OH JES!!
              • Jul 21, 2005
              • 12478

              #21
              Originally posted by spiderrogue
              im gonna get shot..but i despise john byrne for ruining spidey in the late 90's with that relaunch crap...arrrgghhhh....but other than that..i did like his xmen stuff..so that is ok....phew..that was a close one...
              Bleh his late 90's spiderman was horrible...also the X-men the hidden years was not that great also and his Wonder Woman was horrible too. Bryne's artwork for me got uglier because he penciled so loose when others inked him it didn't look right.

              When he did the JLA with Claremont and Ordway. Ordway's inks overpowered Bryne's pencils.

              Comment

              • aquatroy
                Permanent Member
                • Apr 28, 2002
                • 3289

                #22
                I'm a huge fan of his runs on Iron Fist and Captain America.
                Hey! Check out the pictures.

                Comment

                • thunderbolt
                  Hi Ernie!!!
                  • Feb 15, 2004
                  • 34211

                  #23
                  Originally posted by spiderrogue
                  im gonna get shot..but i despise john byrne for ruining spidey in the late 90's with that relaunch crap...arrrgghhhh....but other than that..i did like his xmen stuff..so that is ok....phew..that was a close one...
                  Nahh, no one is going to shoot you for that one. Really bad book and bad Marvel editorial decision for a revamp that wasn't needed.
                  You must try to generate happiness within yourself. If you aren't happy in one place, chances are you won't be happy anyplace. -Ernie Banks

                  Comment

                  • Surfsup
                    Silver Chrome Dome
                    • Dec 2, 2005
                    • 1352

                    #24
                    His first run on the Uncanny X-Men is my favourite with Austin's inks (easily his best inker), closely followed by FF. I don't know what's happened to his art of late but it's absolutely atrocious!

                    Comment

                    • Earth 2 Chris
                      Verbose Member
                      • Mar 7, 2004
                      • 32970

                      #25
                      Yeah, that Spider-Man revamp had to be one of the most univerally loathed "events" in comics. It didn't stick for more than like 5 minutes. About like Mark Waid's Superman:Birthright. DiDio couldn't even decide if it WAS a reboot or not.

                      Chris
                      sigpic

                      Comment

                      • samurainoir
                        Eloquent Member
                        • Dec 26, 2006
                        • 18758

                        #26
                        Originally posted by spiderrogue
                        im gonna get shot..but i despise john byrne for ruining spidey in the late 90's with that relaunch crap...arrrgghhhh....but other than that..i did like his xmen stuff..so that is ok....phew..that was a close one...
                        I think there is a general consensus that Byrne's best days have passed, but he still does do well with a smaller group of fans with the occasional nostalgia driven book like X-Men Hidden Years or Batman/Superman Generations.

                        Doesn't change the fact that he did such wonderful work that is fondly remember by many of us as kids in the seventies/eighties.

                        I wasn't a fan of his Spiderman by any stretch, but I do give him credit for clearing the decks for a more radical approach when they got Bendis for Ultimate Spiderman. Byrne's run also led into one of my personal favourite runs... Paul Jenkins and Mark Buckingham on Peter Parker Spiderman. Filled with small, funny, personal stories. Quite a radically different kind of Spiderman book than we've previously seen, no doubt in response to Byrne's stuff in some way.
                        My store in the MEGO MALL!

                        BUY THE CAPTAIN CANUCK ACTION FIGURE HERE!

                        Comment

                        • samurainoir
                          Eloquent Member
                          • Dec 26, 2006
                          • 18758

                          #27
                          Originally posted by Random Axe
                          A couple of you, myself included, brought up Legends as a Byrne favorite. Anyone know if this was ever collected in a trade? I could always go and get the back issues, but it would be nice to have it all together in one binding.

                          Scott
                          Amazon.com: Legends: The Collection: John Ostrander, Len Wein, John Byrne: Books

                          Can't beat five bucks! John Ostrander's always hugely underrated. I had forgotten that this was a book that Byrne hadn't written himself.

                          I can't quite put my finger on it, but Byrne's DC stuff never really excited me as much as his Marvel stuff.


                          I just read She Hulk #31 for the first time...


                          It probably felt self-indulgent back in the day, but given the seemingly closer proximity to comic book creators now in the internet age, you do have to give credit to Byrne for being able to laugh at himself and his "ego". You have to wonder what happened in the interim, it doesn't seem to be a side that you see much of anymore in his "public persona" online.
                          My store in the MEGO MALL!

                          BUY THE CAPTAIN CANUCK ACTION FIGURE HERE!

                          Comment

                          • The Toyroom
                            The Packaging King
                            • Dec 31, 2004
                            • 16653

                            #28
                            ^ His editor (Renee Witterstater(sp)) looks hot from the back....wonder what she really looks like from the front?
                            Think OUTSIDE the Box! For the BEST in Repro & Custom Packaging!

                            Comment

                            • palitoy
                              live. laugh. lisa needs braces
                              • Jun 16, 2001
                              • 59794

                              #29
                              I got into him from Charlton Space:1999 and his Superman books. I haven't followed his work closely enough in recent years (I really don't read much comics) but I did pick up his recent Doom Patrol stuff and didn't understand how DC could let him rewrite continuity like that. His art seemed to go through a characteristic "Sameness" that seems rampant in older artists, like they only have five facial structures to choose from.

                              I've lurked over at his site occasionally and he really can come off as a jerk sometimes, then again, he doesn't have to have a message board or be in contact with fans at all either.
                              Places to find PlaidStallions online: https://linktr.ee/Plaidstallions

                              Buy Toy-Ventures Magazine here:
                              http://www.plaidstallions.com/reboot/shop

                              Comment

                              • samurainoir
                                Eloquent Member
                                • Dec 26, 2006
                                • 18758

                                #30
                                Originally posted by The Toyroom
                                ^ His editor (Renee Witterstater(sp)) looks hot from the back....wonder what she really looks like from the front?






                                Here she is putting a stop to the Jump Rope stunt...


                                I haven't really read much of his She Hulk, but in this issue there is a supporting character named "Weezi", I'm assuming to be Louise Simonson (nee Jones, editor for Warren and X-Men, writer of Power Pack and Superman)?

                                Not her first incarnation as a comic book character if that is the case...
                                Last edited by samurainoir; May 19, '09, 9:43 AM.
                                My store in the MEGO MALL!

                                BUY THE CAPTAIN CANUCK ACTION FIGURE HERE!

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                😀
                                🥰
                                🤢
                                😎
                                😡
                                👍
                                👎