Help support the Mego Museum
Help support the Mego Museum

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Retro Action figures - rank them!

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • MIB41
    Eloquent Member
    • Sep 25, 2005
    • 15633

    Retro Action figures - rank them!

    I thought it would be interesting if we did a ranking of each character released thus far and a brief reason why. Here are mine:

    1) The Flash - From my perspective he's perfect. A childhood dream fully realized all the way down to the boots. Even Mego wouldn't have done it that good.
    2) Capt Cold - The best Mego or Mego-like villain ever made. I think he trumps them all. Great sculpt, excellent suit, cool accessories, and cool looking boots.
    3) Green Arrow - This figure expands upon the original Mego concept including a vast improvement over the arrow pack design. In the end, a better figure than what Mego put out.
    4) Wonder Woman/Cheetah - (TIE) I rank both high because of two things - A new, vastly improved, female body over the Mego original and well executed design of the outfit and accessories. Anything that can beat the original concept must rank high in my book.
    5) Lex Luthor - Another childhood favorite brought to life. Very good sculpt and a perfect outfit as I envisioned it as a kid. Nice addition with the Kryptonite accessory.
    6) Two-Face - Excellent execution of both sculpt and outfit. A good quality figure and not badly hampered with the body issues due to his suit. Well designed and well thought out.
    7) Sinestro - Given the nature and difficulty of this character's head and facial features, I consider this one a successful effort. Very good sculpt. Would have preferred the yellow outfit. I think that would have given him better contrast in color, but overall a good figure.
    8) Green Lantern - Another childhood favorite brought to life. Overall happy with the character, but I would have liked more detail in the facial features (more defined cheek bones, jaw, and brow arch). Lantern accessory a nice touch.
    9) Manta - Nice villain selection for Aquaman and good sculpt. I liked the way the accessories plug into his head. Nice touch.
    10) Superman - Nice updates on the outfit, but the head a tad too flat for my tastes. And the early body problems expose this particular character from reaching his full potential. Boots a little too thick as well.
    11) Aquaman - A fun figure with a much better suit than the original Mego. The big setback here is the head sculpt. The face is too youthful and the hair is not faithful to most versions of Aquaman we have seen. Honestly, it just doesn't look like him. That and the body issues hurt his ability to pose well.
    12) Batman - I appreciate the ambition and obvious intent with this one. But the RC Batman is a tough project to nail down given the nostalgic loyalty some have to the original and the obvious updates that create a rub against that nostalgia. Here are my thoughts: The Cowl: On it's own merits, the new one is pretty good, but I think it needed expression. Without any emotional register in the cowl, the white eyes make him look blank. As a result he looks too doll-like in the facial region. The gloves are a vast improvement over the Mego oven-mitts and the cape is a nice touch too. What I don't care for is the factory production of the suit. He looks like he's wearing a speedo. And with the body issues at that point, it serves to magnify the flaw that much more. So I certainly give a nod for the effort, but between the quality issues that plagued the line at that point and the nostalgic expectations of many, I think it just had too much working against it.

    It's been the most faithful line up to ever duplicate (or exceed) the Mego experience. 2010 is closing out with a superb wave. Let's ring in the new year with great expectations for more Mego-goodness to come!
    Last edited by MIB41; Dec 10, '10, 3:23 PM.
  • rcbats1
    Banned
    • Nov 1, 2005
    • 0

    #2
    I base my rank on how well they fit in with my vintage Megos first. I cant rank any of the Retros that were made by Mego first until I do my actual favorites below:
    1.Two-Face) He fits in perfectly with vintage Megos....same look...same feel. Perfect. Makes him the best in my opinion so far.
    2.Black Manta) Stick him next to any T2 Mego and he fits in perfectly. The difference in this being #1 and Two-Face being #1 is Two-Face look like a T1 to me and I prefer T1 figures.
    3.Green Lantern) though the head is a bit large it is one of the most Megoey heads of them all.
    4.Captain Cold) Dead on supr nice figure with excellent Mego feel..could be # 1 if I werent a Batman fan!
    5.Flash) A super great figure with another large head...but I've waited 30 yrs for this!
    6(tie).Sinestro,Cheetah and Luthor) I dont have enough #'s to rank them higher or I would.

    Favorites list:

    Two-Face
    Batman (with no eyebrows variant)he'd be # 1 if Two Face wasnt so perfect for my vintage Mego's.
    Flash
    Green Lantern
    Superman( I think this one is very well done and one of my Super favorites)
    Captain Cold
    Sinestro
    Lex Luthor
    Black Manta
    Green Arrow
    Cheetah
    Aquaman
    Wonder Woman

    I love these figures all..and I am very grateful for all the hard work and time that emce has put in to getting this line produced and thank you from the bottom of my heart.

    Comment

    • jemboy2004
      Persistent Member
      • Aug 14, 2005
      • 1703

      #3
      1. Wonder Woman

      2. Cheetah (dreams do come true!)

      3. Lex! Been waiting forever for him and think he's perfect!

      4. Green Lantern I think he's very megoey, perfect IMO

      5. Senestro another great want of mine

      6. Batman I just really like this one

      7. Black Manta simple but another megoey figure and one of my favorite villians

      8. Flash and captain cold both nice figures but don't care for the heads on either

      9. Superman nice figure but like mego version much better

      10. Two face I like the figure it's just I'm not big of a 2 faced fan

      11. Aquaman I think the outfit is good love the trident but the head is not quite right as he looks too young IMO

      Comment

      • david_b
        Never had enough toys..
        • May 9, 2008
        • 2305

        #4
        Originally posted by jemboy2004
        Aquaman I think the outfit is good love the trident but the head is not quite right as he looks too young IMO
        He's perfect for my needs..!!! I finally have my custom Johnny Storm.

        david_b
        Peace.. Through Superior Firepower.

        Comment

        • huedell
          Museum Ball Eater
          • Dec 31, 2003
          • 11069

          #5
          First, I'll comment on the initial post....

          MIB, I have to note that it's a shame that trumping Mego's releases
          are such a big factor in your rankings as, to me, these RAHs overall were
          meant to be an extension of the WGSH line, not competition with them...

          ...but unfortunately due to many quirks in the MATTEL figures, even
          30 years couldn't help MATTEL put out figures that were all undeniably
          as good, or exceeding Mego's take on the WGSH... so, the blame for
          this lands square on MATTEL AFAIC.

          Overall the line is great for kitbashing and customizing...and I think the
          BATMAN may be better than his rep around here would have you think...
          ...round out the top of Supes' head....resculpt Filamtion hair Aquaman's
          boyish face, "eagle-ize" Wonder Woman, and the Mego redos would be a
          heck of a lot better.

          Lucky for many of us, the "new" characters are the best.

          Yeah, basically, all the new characters tied for 1st place...
          SUPES and BATS tied for second, and Aquaman and WW tied for third,
          I'd say.
          "No. No no no no no no. You done got me talkin' politics. I didn't wanna'. Like I said y'all, I'm just happy to be alive. I think I'll scoot over here right by this winda', let this beautiful carriage rock me to sleep, and dream about how lucky I am." - Chris Mannix

          Comment

          • MIB41
            Eloquent Member
            • Sep 25, 2005
            • 15633

            #6
            Just a personal list for fun Huedell. Everyone has their reasons for what they like, just like you. I thought listing the reasons would be helpful to Paul and Emce in identifying any particular trends as to what is favored over others. That's all.

            Comment

            • Brown Bear
              Still Old School
              • Feb 14, 2008
              • 7063

              #7
              I'd say Two-Face is #1 with me, with Lex in at #2.

              That said, I haven't seen Flash in person yet, so he could easily move to #1.
              Check out my website: Megozine Covers - Home

              Comment

              • huedell
                Museum Ball Eater
                • Dec 31, 2003
                • 11069

                #8
                Originally posted by MIB41
                Just a personal list for fun Huedell. Everyone has their reasons for what they like, just like you. I thought listing the reasons would be helpful to Paul and Emce in identifying any particular trends as to what is favored over others. That's all.
                Just to clarify MIB...I wasn't criticizing your thread or post...
                just lamenting that MATTEL fell shorter than I thought they would have
                with some of their manufacturing choices so late in the superhero
                action figure game...so much so that some of the actual figures they're
                tributing are obviously superior.
                "No. No no no no no no. You done got me talkin' politics. I didn't wanna'. Like I said y'all, I'm just happy to be alive. I think I'll scoot over here right by this winda', let this beautiful carriage rock me to sleep, and dream about how lucky I am." - Chris Mannix

                Comment

                • BlackKnight
                  The DarkSide Customizer
                  • Apr 16, 2005
                  • 14622

                  #9
                  1. Green Arrow. This Figure for the Most part Screams Mego Done Better.
                  2. Aquaman See Above .
                  3. Cheeta
                  4. Sinestro
                  5. Two-Face
                  6. Black Manta
                  7. Flash
                  8. Green Lantern
                  9. Superman
                  10. Batman
                  11. WonderWoman
                  12. Captain Cold
                  13. Luthor. Worse PegWarmer thus Far . He's the reason Why You See Wave 2 In Clearance Stores Already. Bad Marketing Move imo. He should have been the Matty Exclusive. No Child Wants this Character, Unless His Parents Preach SuperHeroes in the House.
                  Last edited by BlackKnight; Dec 10, '10, 4:43 PM.
                  ... The Original Knight ..., Often Imitated, However Never Duplicated. The 1st Knight in Customs.


                  always trading for Hot Toys Figures .

                  Comment

                  • SeattleEd
                    SynthoRes Transmigrator
                    • Oct 24, 2007
                    • 4351

                    #10
                    Originally posted by BlackKnight
                    1. Green Arrow. This Figure for the Most part Screams Mego Done Better.
                    Agreed.
                    Haven't gotten W3.

                    Comment

                    • The Bat
                      Batman Fanatic
                      • Jul 14, 2002
                      • 13412

                      #11
                      Green Arrow- LOVE em'...glad to finally own one.
                      Green Lantern-I like him, ok Head Sculpt(biggest complaint long Cuffs)
                      Sinestro-EXCELLENT! Great Sculpt!(but again, too long Cuffs)
                      Lex Luthor-Excellent
                      Superman-hate the Pink Trunks, and Head Sculpt is to generic

                      Aquaman-LOVE this Figure, very Mego! Cuffs now shortened.
                      Two Face-Excellent! Fits in good with my Megos.
                      Batman-HORRIBLE! I absolutely HATE this Figure!
                      Manta-don't care for the Character.

                      Wonder Woman- a MUST buy!
                      Cheeta-eh
                      Cpt.Cold-don't care for the Character.
                      The Flash-TOTAL Bummer. Awful Head Sculpt, I HATE it...won't be buying one.

                      Shazam-don't care for the Character.
                      Black Adam-same deal
                      Martian Manhunter-don't care for the Character.
                      Dark Seid-missed opportunity
                      sigpic

                      Comment

                      • ScottA
                        Original Member
                        • Jun 25, 2001
                        • 12264

                        #12
                        I cannot rank what I don't have yet, which is waves 2 or 3.
                        sigpic WANTED: Boxed, Carded and Kresge Carded WGSH

                        Comment

                        • Zemo
                          Still Smokin'
                          • Feb 14, 2006
                          • 3888

                          #13
                          NO doubt the removable cowl Batman I just picked up at TRU!

                          Comment

                          • Captain
                            Fighting the good fight!
                            • Jun 17, 2001
                            • 6031

                            #14
                            I cant rate a favourite, as I've grown to like them all, even the upcoming stuff. I guess if push came to shove Two Face and Batman would be up there near the top though. The only thing I dont like about Batman, and this is the same thing I would rate as worst issue in the line, is the really off Bruce Wayne likeness.Otherwise, this is the seventies Batman!
                            "Crayons taste like purple!"

                            Comment

                            • kingdom warrior
                              OH JES!!
                              • Jul 21, 2005
                              • 12478

                              #15
                              Originally posted by ScottA
                              I cannot rank what I don't have yet, which is waves 2 or 3.
                              Ditto......

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              😀
                              🥰
                              🤢
                              😎
                              😡
                              👍
                              👎