Totally agree....I have the Identity Crisis Zatanna (based on Turner's art) just to round out my classic JLA line-up and it's a horrible figure in comparision to the top-hat Zatanna that was released a few years prior.
A shame too because I really liked that George Perez costume she wore for a while.
The McGuinness ones all look like the same body pose with a different head....too bulked up IMO.
Comment