BSG is Done

[johnmiic]

I don't want to start a civil war here or get the No Politics Allowed lecture but Ron Moore said in his audio commentary for the most recent season released on DVD that he would have a plot-line where Rosalyn steals an election similar to the 2000 election, ( meaning in the USA). (Paraphrasing).

My info comes from Antonio, who is a member on the boards but has not been posting recently because he is busy with work. I don't want to offend anyone here by saying it or debate this because it gives Brian a headache. It's just what Ron Moore said he was going to do.

[txteach]

I guess the "stolen" American election doesn't count as politics? I want them to leave on a high note.

[johnmiic]

I dunno guys. I think the show ran out of ideas. Many stories are just teasing viewers on Religion and Politics, ( Verbotten subjects in General Buzz!!!!). They keep re-hashing current events like the stolen American election in 2000, or terrorist scenarios since 9/11.

They really haven't done much to search for Earth. That plot is pretty much abandoned and was suppossed to be the basis for Galactica in the first place.

[johnmiic]

You mean no one likes the GAL 1980 episode the Night The Cylons Came where we repeatedly hear about the Meatballs at the Haloween party being bad for you?

Or how about the original plot twist where Troy and Dillon try to escape capture by changing into white tuxedoes and tap dancing on stage with Hanna-Barberra animals?

Or Wolfman Jack guest starring?

I think even Rob Brittanicus would agree-television at it's finest!!!!!

[palitoy]

Only time will tell so it's hard to argue, one thing the new series might do for the old series is elevate it's status a little. In many documentaries and books it's often dismissed as a "Star Wars ripoff", not exactly a grand legacy or a fair shake.

[Mego Maverick]

How much it will be remembered in the future, I don't know. The ratings just aren't there anymore with so many channels. I don't believe the Nielsons ever topped 3.9 and that was the premiere or second night = 4.3 million. BSG in 1978 brought in 60 to 70 million on its premiere, so there are more of our generation to remember it fondly. 20 years from now I think there will be more who remember the original than the remake.

One thing to remember is although the premiere of the Original series did well the ratings quickly plummeted. Which to led to the series only lasting one season. The new series will have lasted (at least) 4 seasons. and will probably have a nice long afterlife in rerun syndication. Which is something the original never really had (until the sci-fi channel and now ion).

It really isn't fair to only look at ratings in this age either. There are several other factors to remember. First is Sci-fi replayed each new episode a couple hours after it originally aired as well as again on Monday nights @11:00. Plus they were constantly doing mini marathons to catch people up. Second is the DVD Box sets. They release them now shortly after the season ends. I have several friends who rarely watch TV shows anymore. They just buy the box sets as soon as they come out and watch them at theis leisure w/out commercials. So I am sure there are much more than 4.3 million BSG fans out there.

As for how it will be remembered, only time will tell. I am a huge fan of both series. More people may remember the original because its original audience were the younger generation, who remember it through the eyes of childhood. Whereas the new series is obviously a far more mature show aimed at us old folks who do remember the original through the eyes of childhood.

[rikitikitavi]

I was a faithful fan of Battlestar Galactica. I still remember watching the premiere of it on September 18, 1978. I also remember Galactica 1980, though I've not seen it since 1980. Yes, I agree, the Return of Starbuck was the best episode. I was not a fan of the new series, so it doesn't mean much to me that it is ending.

How much it will be remembered in the future, I don't know. The ratings just aren't there anymore with so many channels. I don't believe the Nielsons ever topped 3.9 and that was the premiere or second night = 4.3 million. BSG in 1978 brought in 60 to 70 million on its premiere, so there are more of our generation to remember it fondly. 20 years from now I think there will be more who remember the original than the remake.

[trekfan]

The only ep. I Vaguely remember is the one where the BSG kids use advance physics to hit a baseball. Ugggggghhhhh! I don't think I ever watched another episode after that one. In fact, I think it scarred me for life - a grown man that plays with dolls is its side effect.

David

[palitoy]

The only episode worth watching is "The Return of Starbuck".

Ha and that's really just a forgotten episode of BSG. For some reason, I watched every episode of 1980 as a kid. I haven't been able to as an adult.

[toys2cool]

well it was good while it lasted I guess

[Mego Maverick]

I admit I've never seen Galactica 1980, never sounded like I missed anything!

The only episode worth watching is "The Return of Starbuck".

[Mego Maverick]

first SG-1 now BSG I am not sure Atlantis can stand on its own. Sci-fi has said they are trying to get away from the "Space based" sci-fi and more into the fantasy type. But I am not so sure losing 2 staples so close together will be good for the network. I just haven't been able to get hooked on the newer stuff like Eureka and the new Dr. Who.

[Meule]

Is this the one with the female Starbuck and the humanlike Cylons?
They started showing that here couple of week ago. So I'm good for 4 seasons, eh? Cool

[megoscott]

I think they are ready to go. It should be a great season as they head to the finish line. I have a lot of faith in the creators of that show. More nervous about Lost, but it's good they too have an exit strategy in place...

[Wolverine1969]

I admit I've never seen Galactica 1980, never sounded like I missed anything!