Name your favorite Star Trek Enterprise

[B-Lister]

The New Movie version is consistantly scoring last or almost last.

This leads me to wonder how the design ever got approved ?

because Fans (thank goodness) don't make those decisions.

[Doc]

The New Movie version is consistantly scoring last or almost last.

This leads me to wonder how the design ever got approved ?

Amen to that

[Mikey]

The New Movie version is consistantly scoring last or almost last.

This leads me to wonder how the design ever got approved ?

[DocDrako]

Here's my list...

1. NCC-1701-A (Classic Movies)
2. NCC-1701 (TV series)
3. NCC-1701-D (Next Generation Enterprise)
4. NCC-1701-C (Next Gen - Yesterday's Enterprise)
5. NCC-1701-B (Excelsior Class - Generations)
6 NCC-1701-E (Next Gen - First Contact +)
7. NCC-1701 (New Movie)

[jds1911a1]

Only these 3 were ever designed to be "The Enterprise"

1. NCC-1701 (TV series) - an original design like no other!

2. NCC-1701-A (Classic Movies 1-6) - I like most of the upgrade on this design. Especially the interiors of the ship. I think the sides of the engines are wrong. IMHO they should look more like the Excelsior's engines.

3. NCC-1701-D (Next Generation Enterprise) - This was a hard pill to swallow when it first came out; but I get the idea that this design was supposed to be like sculpture. It is unlikely Starfleet would do that but I get it. It's gone anyway so I can accept it.

All of these were named Enterprise by default.

4. NCC-1701-B (Excelsior Class - Generations) - Couldn't just slap a new decal on the model. Berman had to F-it up.

5. NCC-1701-C (Next Gen - Yesterday's Enterprise) - Not a bad design, per se, but it isn't actually the design Andrew Probert came up with.

6 NCC-1701-E (Next Gen - First Contact +) - The designer of this one just swiped details from every ship that didn't match and put them together-mostly the Excelsior. It might be good if certain things on it were changed.

7. NCC-1701 (New Movie) - I don't hate it but there is too much exaggeration on the parts of this ship like it's made of silly putty. It's the Plastic Man Enterprise.

I beleive the redisgn to the B hull from the exceslior were actually driven by the effects people (berman just signed off on the changes). It was purly to prevent damage to the actual model since they were also using it alot for the ST tv shows so they fattened it up to allow them to damage the belly and show exposed to space decks

[jds1911a1]

Whats sad is the 1701 D doesnt even seem to fit in its own universe.

Major battle scenes with Star fleet. (Borg, Dominion War Etc) Only the Galaxy class seems to stand out. Others seem like a logical progression or similar constructed fleet.

It's almost like an ocean liner converted to troop transport duty compared to every other starship design. must have been designed during an extended peace

[jds1911a1]

What no love for the NX-01 from ENTERPRISE but seriously most of them I don't like at all for me it's

1. NCC-1701 classic
2. NCC-1701-A
3. NCC-1701-B
4. NCC-1701-C
5. NCC-1701-E
6. NCC-1701-D
7. NX-01
8. NCC-1701 abrams film

[wyldpny]

1. NCC-1701 (TV series)
2. NCC-1701-A (Classic Movies)
3. NCC-1701-C (Next Gen - Yesterday's Enterprise)
4. NCC-1701-E (Next Gen - First Contact +)
5 NCC-1701-B (Excelsior Class - Generations)
6. NCC-1701-D (Next Generation Enterprise)
7. NCC-1701 (New Movie)

[Mikey]

Even though i'm not a fan of the Enterprise-D and almost hate it I do have some respect for it because it's design was cleared by Gene Roddenberry himself.

It basically looks like a giant behind sat on the movie Enterprise and flattened it out

[johnmiic]

Only these 3 were ever designed to be "The Enterprise"

1. NCC-1701 (TV series) - an original design like no other!

2. NCC-1701-A (Classic Movies 1-6) - I like most of the upgrade on this design. Especially the interiors of the ship. I think the sides of the engines are wrong. IMHO they should look more like the Excelsior's engines.

3. NCC-1701-D (Next Generation Enterprise) - This was a hard pill to swallow when it first came out; but I get the idea that this design was supposed to be like sculpture. It is unlikely Starfleet would do that but I get it. It's gone anyway so I can accept it.

All of these were named Enterprise by default.

4. NCC-1701-B (Excelsior Class - Generations) - Couldn't just slap a new decal on the model. Berman had to F-it up.

5. NCC-1701-C (Next Gen - Yesterday's Enterprise) - Not a bad design, per se, but it isn't actually the design Andrew Probert came up with.

6 NCC-1701-E (Next Gen - First Contact +) - The designer of this one just swiped details from every ship that didn't match and put them together-mostly the Excelsior. It might be good if certain things on it were changed.

7. NCC-1701 (New Movie) - I don't hate it but there is too much exaggeration on the parts of this ship like it's made of silly putty. It's the Plastic Man Enterprise.

[Hector]

I couldn't agree more...
So I don't even consider them...LOL
Plus picard is just captain stubing in space...

Touché!

[knight errant00]

1. NCC-1701-A (Classic Movies -- the perfect rendition of the ship)
2. NCC-1701 (TV series -- the classic I grew up on)
3. NCC-1701-D (Next Generation Enterprise -- simply for the nostalgia of the excitement of ST returning as something new)

I never really cared for any of the rest . . .

4. NCC-1701-C (Next Gen - Yesterday's Enterprise -- OK "intermediate" design)
5. NCC-1701-B (Excelsior Class - Generations -- I would've preferred at least a normal Excelsior-class ship w/o the hull expansions)
6 NCC-1701-E (Next Gen - First Contact - overdesigned)
7. NCC-1701 (New Movie - overdesigned and unbalanced-looking)

[Doc]

Whats sad is the 1701 D doesnt even seem to fit in its own universe.

Major battle scenes with Star fleet. (Borg, Dominion War Etc) Only the Galaxy class seems to stand out. Others seem like a logical progression or similar constructed fleet.

[fallensaviour]

The original TV show, the originals on films, and the new Trek movie....they are all very sexy and streamlined.

I always hated the Next Generations ones...they all look like a giant toilets...

I couldn't agree more...
So I don't even consider them...LOL
Plus picard is just captain stubing in space...

[Hector]

The original TV show, the originals on films, and the new Trek movie....they are all very sexy and streamlined.

I always hated the Next Generations ones...they all look like a giant toilets...