Star Wars : Princess Leia or Queen Amidala

[darklord1967]

...and a coward for "dying" and leaving two little orphans behind.

She died of a broken heart my arse...lol...

http://www.cabbagestew.com/images/padme-dead.jpg

Go ahead...make your 10 page long comeback...

Well, it seems to me that you are overlooking the fact that.... Ahhh... what the hecks the point? No one's gonna read it!!

See, Hector? I AM capable of controlling myself and actually AVOIDING the writting of 10 page posts. See? only 5 short lines.

I still love ya, Darklord!

I love ya back, amigo!

[ScottA]

Sorry, for me it has to be Leia.

[Hector]

Portman and Hayden Christiansen? You'd have better performances if you took a couple of action figures and made em smooch.

I mean, sweet jesus, this is wretched. "I like the water." "I don't like sand." Let's stare at each other and kiss.
YouTube - Anakin Padme kiss part in Star Wars.

Oh my dear God...I had to click stop...I just couldn't watch that entire scene...I almost cringed to death...lol...

[Hector]

Fisher was very pretty back in the day and had (and still has tons more personality) than Portman, which goes a long way for me. While Portman may be conventionally attractive I don't find her "sexy" at all. As for Leia's "*****yness"? That's tons of sexy. Her scenes with Harrison Ford were phenomenal.

Portman and Hayden Christiansen? You'd have better performances if you took a couple of action figures and made em smooch.

I mean, sweet jesus, this is wretched. "I like the water." "I don't like sand." Let's stare at each other and kiss.
YouTube - Anakin Padme kiss part in Star Wars.

Compared to this? This is classic Hollywood romance. They might as well be Bogart and Bacall, it's so good.
YouTube - Star Wars-Empire Strikes Back-Han and Leia-Favorite Scene

Blame a lot of that on declining Lucas storytelling, but also on superior casting (and a different director in Kirshner).

Arguably the BEST darn post on this entire thread...right on the money...agreed on all counts...well said...

[megoscott]

Fisher was very pretty back in the day and had (and still has tons more personality) than Portman, which goes a long way for me. While Portman may be conventionally attractive I don't find her "sexy" at all. As for Leia's "*****yness"? That's tons of sexy. Her scenes with Harrison Ford were phenomenal.

Portman and Hayden Christiansen? You'd have better performances if you took a couple of action figures and made em smooch.

I mean, sweet jesus, this is wretched. "I like the water." "I don't like sand." Let's stare at each other and kiss.
YouTube - Anakin Padme kiss part in Star Wars.

Compared to this? This is classic Hollywood romance. They might as well be Bogart and Bacall, it's so good.
YouTube - Star Wars-Empire Strikes Back-Han and Leia-Favorite Scene

Blame a lot of that on declining Lucas storytelling, but also on superior casting (and a different director in Kirshner).

[jds1911a1]

Well, that would be a qualifying factor as it relates to the "which do you prefer?". I assumed we weren't judging based on acting ability, in which case, there would be a no-prize.

as an actress Portman far outshines carrie fisher (I offer her perfomance in THE PROFESSIONAL when she was 9) but as a character Leia is a more complete person. POrtman's performance in the prequel is a direct shin on how far Lucas stroy telling degraded over the years

BUT while Slave leia is up there with Julie Newmar's catwoman and Lynda carter's wonder woman as a early impure thought I think AOTC portman is way hotter for way longer

[domino]

Padme is cute and all but Leia is far sexier. Being 12 y/o and seeing Leia in that bikini well, I dont have to tell you the thoughts I had.

[The Bat]

Leia. No contest.

Same here! Leia's a Woman...Natalie, while extremely beautiful...seems more like a little Girl.

[Gorn Captain]

To think that Leia seemed to be the only girl in the SW universe in 1977.
That's like one Smurfette, and a hundred Smurfs!!!!!

[D!n0-M@n]

Why not do both? Leia looked good in Jedi and Padme looked good in all three so i'll take the mother daughter combo

I concur! Sounds good to me bro!

[bobws]

Natalie at times has a cuter face but Carrie had it all from day one. i loved watching her walk down the corridors in the white dress with her breasts bouncing along. then laying in the prison cel when being rescued absolutely fabulous. then we get to the bikini...WOW! She takes the prize. Now Natalie in the skintight white outfit is hot as well. and i also wouldn't mind getting both of them

[fallensaviour]

Can I have the slave girl outfit on portman????
I'll take that...Ripped white spandex,that says it all!?!?!?!?

[Hector]

I still love ya, Darklord!

[Hector]

Nicer Personality: I'd have to go with Amidala again. Kind, decent, caring, loving, and romantic...

...and a coward for "dying" and leaving two little orphans behind.

She died of a broken heart my arse...lol...



Go ahead...make your 10 page long comeback...

[darklord1967]

Sexier: Princess Leia (particularly in the Slave girl outfit)

More beautiful: Amidala (by a country MILE!!). Natalie Portman is one of the most beautiful women in hollywood. A perfect face, and sexy in her own right.

Nicer Personality: I'd have to go with Amidala again. Kind, decent, caring, loving, and romantic, versus Leia's biting, stinging, insults and uptight *****iness.