Star Trek vs Star Wars .. who really would win ?

[Mikey]

Ok,
The entire Star Trek universe teams up (including baddies) and the entire Star Wars universe teams up (including baddies) for the ultimate war.

Who would win ?

I have to give this one to Trek easy.

[Dave Mc]

I seem to remember some weird guy joining Rebelscum and posting this thread a few years back. Not sure what happened to that guy, but I recall the RS people popping a nut.

[Mego Milk]

The Wookiees would win!

[toys2cool]

Star wars hands down,they have the Power of the Sith and Jedi's combined not to mention Death Stars that could blow up whole planets

Sorry but you Trekies would'nt stand a chance

[Mikey]

I seem to remember some weird guy joining Rebelscum and posting this thread a few years back. Not sure what happened to that guy, but I recall the RS people popping a nut.

Yea, who was that guy ?

[Mikey]

Star wars hands down,they have the Power of the Sith and Jedi's combined not to mention Death Stars that could blow up whole planets

Sorry but you Trekies would'nt stand a chance

I hate to bring out the big guns so early, but Q could destroy the entire Star Wars universe single-handedly

[UnderdogDJLSW]

It would be cool to see the Sith battling the Borg. I t would be interesting since they do not have an individual mind, would mind tricks work on them?

[toys2cool]

It would be cool to see the Sith battling the Borg. I t would be interesting since they do not have an individual mind, would mind tricks work on them?

No but a lightsaber across the head will do

[UnderdogDJLSW]

But the Borg adapt and they could probably create a force field that would repel the saber after the first dozen of them went down.

[Captain]

The enemy James T. Kirk cannot beat hasnt been created yet. Star Trek would handily trounce Star Wars!

[TEXASFETT]

Just like how DC had fought Marvel in the comics.Some how make worlds collide with Star Wars and Star Trek in some kind of story. Its bound to happen one day. Still think the bounty hunters would be collecting vulcan ears rather than wookie braids.LOL!!!Even have the Falcon beat on the Enterprise!!! Q shomew forgot about blah blah and more blah.Even the fan boys would whip his @s s!!!!

[thunderbolt]

The Klingons would be eating Stormtrooper soup for years.

[johnmiic]

Well, I think Trek has the advantage as far as technology. All the weapons in Star Trek seem more advanced than what they have in Star Wars. Phasers will slice and dice any ship from Star Wars. The advantage Star Wars has is sheer size and numbers. The Imperial and Rebel ships dwarf most Starfleet vessels. They have more power tho their weaons are less sophisticated. Also Star Trek doesn't have fighter ships. I can see wave after wave of tie fighters attacking the Trek ships in a battle. As long as the shields are up it's no problem but can they adequately target and destroy the endless supply of fighters which are far more manuverable? At some point the Trek ships will run out of power and get worn down unless they can retreat and re-group. If the Borg and the Empire went up against each other I don't think a Borg win would be guaranteed. Any battle would not be so simple. It would depend on many different things.

Can Trek fight the power of the Force? The Vulcans are telepathic but could they withstand the Force? Maybe it wouldn't even affect them? As we saw in Epsiodes 1 & 6 some beings are immune to the Force. Watto and Jabba cannot be influenced and strangely enough they are non-humanoid. Does that mean only humans can be swayed? Would we have to see Horta or Gorn marines take on the Empire? Vader and The Emperor have limits too. Notice that Vader has not choked anyone using the dark side fo the force that he could not see. Otherwise why didn't he choke Han Solo to prevent the Falcon from getting away in Empire? Or Lando or the Princess when Luke was rescued in that same film? Why not use the Force to prevent the torpedo from going down the shaft in Star Wars and save the Death Star? Also in Star Wars tho his tie fighter spun out of control Vader had to regain control of it himself. He relied on his pilot's skills. There was never any indication of him using the Force to get out of that tight spot.

[Gorn Captain]

Doctor Who wins.

He's got a time machine....

[MarkStalcup]

Star Wars wins. Alas, Spock and Kirk then jump in a time machine and fix things so Star Trek wins. Notably, Padme still dies. However, she's now played by Joan Collins. In a freak side effect, fans of both genres suddenly become love gods to all the ladies, and the surest way to get booty on a Friday night is to wear a Boba Fett costume to the local nightclubs.