GMEN SuperBowl Champs !

[toys2cool]

Well sure Brady's got 3 rings and you can't take that away but he's got two loses in the Super Bowl and BOTH of them against the Giants and you certainly can't discount that either.

Here's the thing with this game...if Brady won, he's in Joe Montana territory even with the one loss four years ago. Now he's in John Elway territory...still good but not the best. For Eli if he lost he would have been 1-1 and then there's the talk that maybe 07 was a fluke and the Pats got revenge but now he's 2-0, the Super Bowl MVP twice and he (and Coughlin) are going to the Hall of Fame regardless of what happens in the future. Not to mention he's also just become the greatest Quarterback in New York history....bigger than Simms and even bigger than Namath. So this game was a tale of two legacies going in different directions.

I thought he was already the best QB in NY even before this game

[Jordiway]

Well sure Brady's got 3 rings and you can't take that away but he's got two loses in the Super Bowl and BOTH of them against the Giants and you certainly can't discount that either.

Here's the thing with this game...if Brady won, he's in Joe Montana territory even with the one loss four years ago. Now he's in John Elway territory...still good but not the best. For Eli if he lost he would have been 1-1 and then there's the talk that maybe 07 was a fluke and the Pats got revenge but now he's 2-0, the Super Bowl MVP twice and he (and Coughlin) are going to the Hall of Fame regardless of what happens in the future. Not to mention he's also just become the greatest Quarterback in New York history....bigger than Simms and even bigger than Namath. So this game was a tale of two legacies going in different directions.

*** are you talking about Brady is the BEST there ever is ever was!!!!!!

[toys2cool]

you think Charger fans are furious right now? after what he did in the draft? They get stuck with Rivers and SB's , I guess Eli and his dad knew what they were doing all along

[BlackKnight]

I thought he was already the best QB in NY even before this game

Well, campaired to Sanchez, Without a Doubt.

[BlackKnight]

you think Charger fans are furious right now? after what he did in the draft? They get stuck with Rivers and SB's , I guess Eli and his dad knew what they were doing all along

I like Rivers personally ..., But the Chargers Had Breeze ...., and look how they F'ed that up. If I were them, I'd be more ****ed off at thier own organization.

[spacecaps]

^^^ But Elway Went out on Top. And when He won his 2 SB's ...., He then retired, and was the Best of the Best when he left. imo.

Right..Elway lost his first three and got two back to back and then retired on top. Brady won his first three but then lost his next two. The last two are by far the two most important Super Bowls he's played in...'07 was for history and tonight was for his legacy. That's why I say they're similar even though Brady's got one more ring. Both of them are a tier lower than Montana and Bradshaw. Had Brady won tonight the victory would have placed him in that top tier category.

[MegoMark71]

Damn guys it's a dang sport but this thread is so full of hate. Congrats to eli and the Giants cause it is a team game.

[toys2cool]

I like Rivers personally ..., But the Chargers Had Breeze ...., and look how they F'ed that up. If I were them, I'd be more ****ed off at thier own organization.

I love Rivers to, but still they have to be thinking what the ****?! yea the Bree's move has to hurt as well , i forgot about that one

[MegoMark71]

Did Brady say he was going to retire? Pretty sure he has some years left in him.

[toys2cool]

Damn guys it's a dang sport but this thread is so full of hate. Congrats to eli and the Giants cause it is a team game.

naw I hate the Pats but even I have to admit that's a great team.....no hate from me, i was rooting for Eli, but I'm not an idiot, I know how good Brady is

[BlackKnight]

Damn guys it's a dang sport but this thread is so full of hate.

Thats what Brady does ..., He ruins the Game. Nuff Said.

[spacecaps]

*** are you talking about Brady is the BEST there ever is ever was!!!!!!

No...if he won tonight he could have been in that discussion. (I wouldn't make the argument for him but someone could) Now there is no discussion. He's not the "best ever" and really after two HUGE Super Bowl losses, he can never really be considered that now.

[Jordiway]

No...if he won tonight he could have been in that discussion. (I wouldn't make the argument for him but someone could) Now there is no discussion. He's not the "best ever" and really after two HUGE Super Bowl losses, he can never really be considered that now.

Anybody got better stats? i think not!!!!

[Spawn67]

Glad to see the Cheatriots lost! Karma's a *****! Although need I mention what team would have DESTROYED the Giants in the super bowl (again)!
But either way Im glad the Pats lost!

[spacecaps]

I thought he was already the best QB in NY even before this game

I'd did too. But up here after the 08 season a lot of Giants fans were calling 07 a fluke and were considering him lucky. Not all Giants fans mind you but still enough. It's almost like they didn't give him enough credit for '07. Tonight he silenced all of that forever.