Annual Fav Scrooges thread

[Mikey]

Name your top 3 favorite Scrooges in order ...

My list .......

1. Albert Finney (Thank you very much)

2. Alastair Sim

3. Mr MaGoo

[kingdom warrior]

Ha i was thinking about this!!!

1. Albert Finney all time fav and yes love the Song Thank you very much!
2. George C. Scott dramatic version.
3. Alastair Sim in 'A Christmas Carol' animated actually scariest of them all
4. Alastair Sim in 1951 version
5. Muppet's 'A Christmas Carol'
6. Scrooge McDuck in 'Mickey's Christmas Carol'
7. Mr.Magoo 'Christmas Carol'
8. Patrick Stewart in 'A Christmas Carol'
9. jim carrey 'A Christmas Carol' my new fav
10.Bill Murray 'Scrooged'

[megomania]

Bill Murray in 'Scrooged' and Mr. Magoo..otherwise not much into 'A Christmas Carol'

[JediJaida]

Alastair Sim in both versions of Scrooge.

Albert Finney.

George C. Scott.

Mr. Magoo.

Scrooge McDuck.

Bill Murray.

Reginald Owen. (back in the 30's).

Henry Winkler.

[The Toyroom]

Mr. Sim....the ONLY Scrooge for me...

[HardyGirl]

In no particular order:

George C. Scott
Patrick Stewart
Alastair Sim
Mister Magoo

And the female versions:
Ebony Scrooge (as played by Vanessa Williams in A Diva's Christmas Carol)
Ebbie (as played by Susan Lucci in Ebbie)
Ms. Scrooge (as played by Cicely Tyson in Ms. Scrooge)

[jimsmegos]

Bill Murray

Scrooge McDuck

The others are all too similar... not bad.. just similar

[johnnystorm]

Sim is my classic Scrooge. Always have a soft spot for the first version of a Christmas Carol I ever saw, one of those Hanna-Barbera FAMOUS CLASSIC TALES cartoons they used to run on Saturday afternoons during the fall back in the 70s.

[Goblin19]

Alistair Sim is by far my favorite.

[DocDrako]

Alastair Sim. I'm a fan of the animated Jim Carrey film, but Sim is my favorite.