Billy Joel vs Elton John

[Mikey]

Who wins the contest for most annoying songs ?

I have to give the prize to Billy

Who get's your vote ?

[domino]

I dont like either but I think Billy is a little worse.

[huedell]

For me, Billy's worst may be the "most annoying"
("Tell Her About it" "Uptown Girl" "I Go To Extremes"
etc.)
but...
I'm so nonplussed about ELTON material that I'd say
I'm basically "bored" by just about EVERYTHING Elton
has ever released.

While on the flipside, I think everything Billy released from
1971 (COLD SPRING HARBOR) up until 1982 (NYLON CURTAIN)
is a perfect set of releases. Nine tight albums.

[Mikey]

A lot of Billy songs make me want to tell him JUST SHUT UP

a few examples ....
Move'in Out
You May Be Right
Big Shot
My Life
Only the good dye young

[darklord1967]

I love the music of BOTH Elton and Billy.

[MegoMark71]

My last radio job was working at a station that played adult contemporary so i pretty much hate them both with added vigor.

[huedell]

Move'in Out
You May Be Right
Big Shot
My Life
Only the good dye young

Those are some of his best in my opinion

[Seeker]

I love the music of BOTH Elton and Billy.

Sorry I'm with him. I like both.

[jessica]

Sorry I'm with him. I like both.

Me too.

[The Bat]

Abodolutely HATE Billy Joel...so that's an easy one! I like a couple of Elton Songs...but wouldn't call myself a Fan.

[garagesale]

I'd like to see them in a cage match.

JamesD

[toys2cool]

They both have good songs but I find them both annoying

[Dave Mc]

I grew up listening to Elton John. He was one of those major stars of my youth that I latched onto. So to this day I'm still an Elton John fan. I don't have much use for his post 70's stuff, but his 70's music is still some of my favorite stuff.

I also like most pre-Christie Brinkley era Billy Joel.

So to sum up, I'm a fan of both.

[thunderbolt]

Pretty sure most know where I stand on this one. And Elton ain't far behind.

[fallensaviour]

I love the music of BOTH Elton and Billy.

Same here,not all but most.