List your top ten favorite Superhero films

[Brue]

talk about a thread coming back fro the dead - the last post was Dec 2007.

but what the hey:

Loved these (not necessarily in this order) I can't get it down to 10 -is 17 OK?:

Dark Knight
Iron Man
Spider-Man
Incredibles
Conan the Barbarian (arnold)
Superman II
Batman Mask of the Phantasm
Batman (89)
X-Men
Iron Man 2
Spider-Man 2
X2
Captain America
V for Vendetta
Flash Gordon
Batman Forever (- stop lumping it in with Batman and Robin)
Watchmen


next tier:

Superman the movie
Batman Returns
Batman Begins
Sin City
Daredevil (i know I am going against popular opinion here but I loved this)
Thor
The Crow
Rocketeer
Batman (66)
Incredible Hulk
X-Men First Class
X-Men Last Stand
Spawn
Blade

[Operation:Mego]

Nope, not dead yet. A bump with recent movies:

Only 10? [email protected], here goes!

1. The Dark Knight (2008) - 9.3

2. Batman Begins (2005) - 9.1

3. Thor (2011) - 9

4. X2: X-Men United (2003) - 8.9

5. Daredevil: Extended Cut (2004) - 8.85

6. Spider-Man 2.1 (2007) - 8.84

7. X-Men Origins: Wolverine (2009) - 8.8

8. Spider-Man 2 (2004) - 8.79

9. The Incredible Hulk (2008) - 8.7

10. Captain America: The First Avenger (2011) - 8.65

Honorable mentions:

Spider-Man 3 (8.64)
Superman Returns (8.6)
Spider-Man (8.55)
Green Lantern (8.5)
Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer - (8.49)
Fantastic Four (8.45)
The Punisher (8.45)
Hulk (8.4)
Daredevil (8.3)
Elektra (8.25)
Punisher: War Zone (8.25)
Ghost Rider (8)

Movies I haven't seen:

Superman: The Motion Picture, Superman II, Superman II: The Ricard Donner Cut, Superman III, Superman IV: The Queast for Peace, Batman, Batman Returns, Batman Forever, Batman and Robin, Iron Man, Iron Man 2, X-Men: First Class, etc.

[ozcollector1992]

Batman and Robin (first comic one I saw)
X-3
X-2 (All were so good. Shawn Ashmore is the best)
X-1
Superman
Fantastic 4
Superman 2
Rise of the Silver Surfer
Ghost Rider
Superman Returns

[The Bat]

BATMAN BEGINS(The greatest of ALL Superhero Flims IMO)
The Incredibles
Superman
Superman 2
Superman Returns
X-Men
X-Men 2
Spiderman
Spiderman 2
Spiderman 3

I wanted to add "The Matrix"! If You think about...it IS a Superhero Film.

*Note*I didn't realize this was an old Thread bumped up...so I posted again...added Spidey 3 & The Incredibles.

[Bo8a_Fett]

1 Hellboy
2 rocketeer
3 Superman 2 (Donner cut)
4 Batman Begins
5 Mystery Men
6 Fantastic Four 2 (dissapointing but slowly going in the right direction)
7 Batman:Mask of the Phantasm
8 Unbreakable
9 The Crow
10 Judge Dredd (so much was RIGHT for this movie but was spoiled by Dredd unmasked)

[jds1911a1]

there are ALOT of superhero movies and I assume we are focusing on those that actually got released or were planned for theatrical release (like the 90 capt america and 88 punisher) excluding planned direct to vid/dvd feature lenght and TV movies (or 1978 Capt America would have been on my list)

Not even Close
X 3 Last stand- worst of the 3 by far
Hulk
Daredevil
Superman 4
Fantastic 4 2005
Ghost Rider
Batman and Robin
batman Forever

Close but no cigar
Batman 1966
Spiderman 3 ( the worst of the 3 but still decent)
Captain America 1990 - red skull is italian ??? otherwise decent
Superman 3 only for the clark vs evil superman fight
batman Returns

10 Superman 2 - before I saw the Donner cut this might not even have made the top 10
9 X2 X men united
8 Superman Returns (I really like this but I love the first Reeves one)
7 Batman Begins
6 Spiderman 2 (in know many people think it's better than 1 but much like arguing if A new hope or Empire is better it's a very close call)
5 X men
4 Batman Mask of the Phantasm
3 Batman 1989
2 Spiderman (2000)
1 Superman The Movie

[jemboy2004]

1. superman returns- yeah it's my favorite hero film!

2. Batman Returns- Love this one. Only thing I didn't like about this one was Catwomans costume.

3. Star crossed. I loved this justice league movie alot.

4. X-men 2

5. x-men 1

6. x-men 3 I liked them all about the same

7. spiderman 3 I really like this one more than the other 2 but they are all about equal to me

8. spiderman 2 first time seeing I thought too much time spent on the mary jane but seeing it the second time I liked it more the second time around.

9. spiderman 1

10. spawn

[kinostadt]

Oh my dear lord.....ROTFLMFAO!!!

It's only fitting.....

Turkish Superman

Man, those wacky Turks are the best, thanks for hooking me up, lol.

I think model in the flying shots is actually a Madelman Superman.

[Alberto Malnati]

hmm, here my list
1)batman begins:excellent movie, also people that don't love comics heroes appreciated it.
2)x men 2: , good story, well realized a good movie,
3)batman return : great cast and nice Gothic ambiance
4)Spider man : good compromise between comics an movie fiction, great baddie
5)xman3: still good after 3 episodes...not easy to keep a good quality
6)spider man 2: great actions scenes...but i didn't love so much doc oc
7)x men : nice for a comics lover, not fantastic, but good.
8)Bat man: well, i really loved it when i saw the first time...but honestly it isn't a masterpiece...but still it give me some fun
9) hulk: well it's very well done...i didn't like so much the baddie daddy Banner but i've really enjoyed the combats scenes with the Army
10) daredevil: i didn't like kingping too far from the comics character...and bullseye too don't satisfied me so much... honestly it really a bad movie...but i love so much the character that i can still watch it
ciao
Al

[Brue]

As I did with least favorites, I have tallied the members votesa here.

Recieveing the most votes:

1 Superman: The Motion Picture (13)
2 Batman Begins (13) (I'll take liberty of ranking newer movies below older ones b/c they have not taken the test of time yet)
3 Spider-man (12)
4 X2 (11)
5 Superman II (10)
6 Spider-man 2 (10)
7 Batman (1989) (7)
8 X-Men (7)
9 Superman Returns (7)
10 Batman: Mask of the Phantasm (6)
11 FF: Rise of the Silver Surfer (6) - definitely hasn't stood the test of time yet!

honorable mentions:

V for Vendetta, Rocketeer, Hellboy, Incredibles

A reminder of the Worst list:
1 Hulk 13
2 B & R 12 (also received one vote for best films -starbuk)
3 Catwoman 12
4 Superman IV 11

[Earth 2 Chris]

Counting or not, Mask of Zorro is a great movie. The sequel is okay, but they waited too long, or something. Still not bad.

Chris

[Brue]

1. Superman 1 and 2 (I consider them one movie)

7. The Mask of Zorro (does it count?)

I'd say most definitely - cape: check, mask, - check, dual ID, rescues, people, action - check check check. And I agree it is a great movie. (the 2nd wasn't so hot though)

[boynightwing]

1. Superman 1 and 2 (I consider them one movie)
2. Batman Begins
3. The Crow
4. X2
5. Spiderman
6. V for Vendetta
7. The Mask of Zorro (does it count?)
8. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
9. Rise of the Silver Surfer
10. Mask of the Phantasm.

[toys2cool]

In no particular order

Batman 1

Daredevil

Ghostrider

FF Silver surfer

Spiderman 1

X-men 1

Sin City

Batman Begins

Conan

He-man (not sure if it falls in the super hero category) yes the Dolph one

[Brue]

I've only discovered it today, but I'm going to nominate Turkish Batman.

Great entertainment.

I have to agree - great entertainment. Thanks for posting it. Not exactly top 10 material but entertaining just the same.