Who would be in your JSA

[jds1911a1]

Right. It had the black hawk symbol on the forehead. I always really liked that one.

Chris

Me too much preferred that over the ski mask

[Cosmicman]

Powergirl
Earth Two Superman (Bring him back dammit)
Hawkman
Hourman
Dr. Midnite
Flash (Garrick)
Green Lantern (Scott)
Dr. Fate (reduce his powers)
Stargirl
Atom Smasher (Hey, I liked this guy. I don't like new Damage guy)
Huntress (put the new one on the team)
Wildcat
Nightwing (Stick him on the team as a E2 Robin idea)

'nuff said

[jds1911a1]

Powergirl
Earth Two Superman (Bring him back dammit)
Hawkman
Hourman
Dr. Midnite
Flash (Garrick)
Green Lantern (Scott)
Dr. Fate (reduce his powers)
Stargirl
Atom Smasher (Hey, I liked this guy. I don't like new Damage guy)
Huntress (put the new one on the team)
Wildcat
Nightwing (Stick him on the team as a E2 Robin idea)

'nuff said

do you actually prefer nightwing to the e2 robin? IMO everything nightwing was in the 80's was cloned from e2 robin in the 70's (and since you are advocating e2 superman why not e2 Robin too)

Which Dr fate (each incarnation was very different) or did you really want the half helmeted fate from the mid 40's and All star squadron?

For hawkman which version modern retcon reborn, elder statesman (late 70's All star comics-1992), or youthfull golden/silver age a la all star squadron and JSA crossovers of the 60's) and which mask

[Cosmicman]

do you actually prefer nightwing to the e2 robin? IMO everything nightwing was in the 80's was cloned from e2 robin in the 70's (and since you are advocating e2 superman why not e2 Robin too)

Which Dr fate (each incarnation was very different) or did you really want the half helmeted fate from the mid 40's and All star squadron?

For hawkman which version modern retcon reborn, elder statesman (late 70's All star comics-1992), or youthfull golden/silver age a la all star squadron and JSA crossovers of the 60's) and which mask

Oh my god! Someone noticed I was here.

Well in that case, I will explain my thoughts then!

Well you have to think. We are talking about nowadays in the comics. They did bring back Earth Two Superman and then killed him off. Why not create some story where he comes back from the dead? They did it with this Superman, why not him? I have a feeling that is going to happen anyway.

Earth Two Robin can't be used because he was technically killed in Crisis and never brought back. Why not use Nightwing? Perfect idea? Have him "fill in" for the missing spot where E2 Robin was plucked from existence. I am with Chris on that, I always liked E2 Robin as a kid. I think that is why I can relate with Chris's taste a bit here. E2 Robin was one of the main megos I customized last year.

As for Hawkman. I like how they made him into DC's Wolverine. Keep that version in this mix. The personalities would click well with this breed of characters. To be honest, he was a little lame. I just picked up the whole entire series of All Star Squadron in Adobe Acrobat form. I like how they wrote him in these retconned stories in the 80s. I wouldn't mind that version either.

I think I would like some form of Doctor Fate on this team, but he would have to be powered down because it would be worthless to have half of this team to be there with a guy that powerful. I don't like the idea how he was in All Star Squadron. Maybe give him a weakness, make him only be able to do so much in a day without being exhausted. Simple right?

[jds1911a1]

Oh my god! Someone noticed I was here.

Well in that case, I will explain my thoughts then!

Well you have to think. We are talking about nowadays in the comics. They did bring back Earth Two Superman and then killed him off. Why not create some story where he comes back from the dead? They did it with this Superman, why not him? I have a feeling that is going to happen anyway.

Earth Two Robin can't be used because he was technically killed in Crisis and never brought back. Why not use Nightwing? Perfect idea? Have him "fill in" for the missing spot where E2 Robin was plucked from existence. I am with Chris on that, I always liked E2 Robin as a kid. I think that is why I can relate with Chris's taste a bit here. E2 Robin was one of the main megos I customized last year.

As for Hawkman. I like how they made him into DC's Wolverine. Keep that version in this mix. The personalities would click well with this breed of characters. To be honest, he was a little lame. I just picked up the whole entire series of All Star Squadron in Adobe Acrobat form. I like how they wrote him in these retconned stories in the 80s. I wouldn't mind that version either.

I think I would like some form of Doctor Fate on this team, but he would have to be powered down because it would be worthless to have half of this team to be there with a guy that powerful. I don't like the idea how he was in All Star Squadron. Maybe give him a weakness, make him only be able to do so much in a day without being exhausted. Simple right?

For Fate
It sounds like you really want the half helmet Kent neslon Dr fate power level where he was more of a magic wielding GA superman but I mean which host ,Kent Nelson, Hec Hall, NABU, either of the the JLA versions etc) see the entire pre crisis all star squadrons except the issues with Spectre & KULAK (I don't have them handy so I am going from memory 38-39?)

I like the justification of nightwing then (but in my mind I ma ignoring the Big DC events since they retcon so often and just taking the ones I want from all eras of the JSA) I was torn between E2 Robin and Huntress when I started but I so wanted Helena in the team.
my Modern history post crisis JSA is almost the same:
GL Alan Scott
Flash Jay Garrick
Wildcat
Hawkman - Pre rebirth Carter Hall ala 70's
Dr Fate kent Nelson
Mr terrific Terry Sloan
Sandman
Johnny Thunder (with the thunderbolt who was the trickter like in golden age)

[The Toyroom]

Sounds like a lot of people were influenced by the JSA from the "All-Star Comics" 70s revival (as well as their appearances in "Adventure Comics")...that's the JSA I grew up with. I like that era better than the Golden Age JSA.

[The Toyroom]

[B]Earth Two Robin can't be used because he was technically killed in Crisis and never brought back. Why not use Nightwing? Perfect idea? Have him "fill in" for the missing spot where E2 Robin was plucked from existence.

If you like Earth-2 Robin go with him instead of Nightwing. Ignore continuity...DC does after all! I've got a soft spot myself for Earth-2 Robin and would love to see him and the Earth-2 Huntress brought back (the right way...not the New "Earth-2" from the "52-niverse" way).

[jds1911a1]

If you like Earth-2 Robin go with him instead of Nightwing. Ignore continuity...DC does after all! I've got a soft spot myself for Earth-2 Robin and would love to see him and the Earth-2 Huntress brought back (the right way...not the New "Earth-2" from the "52-niverse" way).

52niverse that is great i almost choked

[jds1911a1]

Sounds like a lot of people were influenced by the JSA from the "All-Star Comics" 70s revival (as well as their appearances in "Adventure Comics")...that's the JSA I grew up with. I like that era better than the Golden Age JSA.

Loved that run. so nice to see the JSA monthly rather than having to wait for the summer crossover of waiting for Barry to visit Jay.

[The Toyroom]

^ I'm glad that the summer JLA/JSA cross-overs are back...I really missed them since they stoped doing them after Crisis On Infinite Earths.

[jds1911a1]

I haven't been buying on newsstands for a while I generally wait for TPB's now (monthly comics are just so expensive) BUT If JLA and JSA teamups are back I may have to pay more attention to the monthlies