Screen accurate or comic book accurate

[dreddbatfan]

I plan on doing a Phantom 8" and 12" figure in the future and I'm not sure what version that I should do.Below is the screen version as played by Billy Zane and below that one is the comic book version.The only difference are the trunks.Which one do you think that I should do?Please chime in with your opinion and the one with the most votes is the one that I'll do in both a 8 & 12 inch figure(I like both,that's why I'm asking everyboidys opinion).

sdcc09_391.jpgPhantom-25-00.jpg

[Mego Magyar]

I always prefer comic version over screen.

[boss]

I'm usually happy when they end up looking somewhat close to the character. ;-)

[mishu2nite]

Comic for sure, let hot toys make screen aacurate stuff.

[HumanWolfman]

I go for comic accurate myself.

[MIB41]

I think it will be too cool to see a Billy Zane version. Castaway really nailed the comic book look. I think the movie version would be a cool challenge.

[Figuremod73]

I prefer the comic version usually. Like you said they are alot alike though.

[kingdom warrior]

Do The Billy Zane costume...that was a badass version of the costume, the skull was silk screened on to it giving it a really awesome look......and I agree Castaway already nailed the comic version.

[GlobalObserver]

Do both, and make extras to sell to people like me who have no customizing ability whatsoever.

I'd also love to have a Julie Walker figure.

[TMANSTOYS]

Go comic. Its the only way.

[GlobalObserver]

Like MIB41 said, Castaway pretty much nailed the 8" comics Phantom: Including purple, olive, grey, & red variants. A Swedish blue variant would be awesome.

[thunderbolt]

would love to see someone do the movie version, that was cool design.

[Boywonder0]

My vote is for comic book accurate renditions.

[Timothy2251]

I lean towards comic accurate myself, but since Castaway nailed the Phantom right out of the gate, and if you already have one, go for the movie version.

[dr_cyclops]

I'm such a true to the comic fan. Something about a 'Swedish blue comic variant' sounded so sweet to me.