Baggies, the facts!

[Remco Monster]

You know, after reading all of this, I get the impression that the bags with writing were never really intended for any of the SI figures, but that they either ran out of plain bags, or just grabbed a wrong/random box, and a bunch of SI suits got the bags with writing.

Two things lead me to believe this. One that not all of the SI bags have writing, and two, the whole "powder" thing makes more sense with the Big Jim figures and their rubber arms.

[megozilla13]

for mailer box figures I've seen two different types of plastic material used for the baggies. One is real crinkley and the other is softer. I recently bought a set of bagged woz figures and one had a baggie that opened from the side, not the top. I thought that was unusual.

Provenence....... your right. I know I didn't switch the bags, but how do I know the original owner, didn't also have the Big Jim Mego outfits and switched the bags. Or better yet, how do I know that back in Hong Kong the box of baggies intended to be used for the SI's was somehow misplaced and the factory worker responsible for bagging the SI's didn't walk over to the guy bagging the Mego Big Jim outfits and grabbed a couple from him.


mikej

[warlock664]

Baggies

IMO, the important thing is disclosure. While I wouldn't personally be that bugged knowing my SI baggies came from Action Jackson outfits instead of SI sets, I'd certainly want to know if a switch had been made. If I found out later that they had been switched without that fact being revealed, I'd feel uncomfortable about the authenticity of the sets as well, though of course those are much harder to fake.
Hmmm, if all those white AJ cleats were free of holes (from being stitched to backing cards), how many footwear switches would have been made for Peter Parker without disclosure ?

[LonnieFisher]

When you're talking original there is a world of difference. ORIGINAL is not something that has been switched.

"Not derived from something else" is the definition that applies here.

[Orlock]

I know this whole discussion over this had me going "ehhhh..." and feeling a tad bit uncomfortable when the "switched baggies" gauntlet was thrown down. I always thought it was more along the lines of honesty is the best policy and not misrepresenting something. That's the only way to tell on some things what came from where is totally and completely relying on someone else's prior knowledge of an item. Dishonesty being thrown into that kind of sullies the experience...you know?

It may honestly not matter one way or another, if they are truly 100% identical, but still, it just doesn't feel right to me.

[clemso]

After the recent SI Baggie thread, what are the baggie facts and opinions.
Are Mad Monster baggies the same as American West, what other baggies are the same?
Does anyone really even care if its just a clear bag?
Provenance? Honestly how can you even prove the bag is really the bag, if you know what i mean.