Dr Who Cliffhanger Tonight

[Mikey]

I think RTD did a great job re-designing the Daleks.

I totally agree.

The RTD Daleks were the first Daleks since the Cushing movies that didn't look fragile.

RTD Daleks were meatie and had a steampunk look.

[wolfie]

Did anybody spot the Thunderbirds moment with Lady Penelope and Parker, i just fell off the chair laughing. Great stuff.

[johnmiic]

I think RTD did a great job re-designing the Daleks. They looked lean and mean. I think Moffat went the wrong way in his re-design. Just make the fat Daleks the leaders and keep the RTD Daleks as the soldiers. Keep the military green color scheme for a while too. There should be some variation and specialization in the Daleks. He kind'a blew that last season when he had the new ones start exterminating the old ones. They should not all be exactly the same. The rainbow colors don't help either.

[Gorn Captain]

yeah but nobody likes them.

True. Why don't they reinvent them...back to the way they were? The way everybody has loved them for 50 years.

[Mikey]

A lot of people seem to forget the Daleks didn't make all that many appearances on Classic episodes.
Many Classic Doctors only had 1 Dalek story including ...

Sly McCoy
Colin Baker
Peter Davison

Heck, Tom Baker's 7 year stretch only produced 2 Dalek stories.

[YANOULI]

I liked it, but I felt the whole thing was a bit rushed.
With all this going on, I would have thought that the Doctor getting his allies together and the actual fight would have been more elaborate. If they could spend two eps on doppelgangers, I would have liked to have seen more of this conflict.

I agree, where were the Sontaran and Cyberman fleets?
Battle of Demons run? Not what i'd call it.

As for reinventing the Daleks once again. Yawn!!!!
What are they going to have now? Legs? A trolley cart behind them for their shopping? Didn't they reinvent their look last season already?

yeah but nobody likes them.

[Gorn Captain]

I liked it, but I felt the whole thing was a bit rushed.
With all this going on, I would have thought that the Doctor getting his allies together and the actual fight would have been more elaborate. If they could spend two eps on doppelgangers, I would have liked to have seen more of this conflict.

When they got to the big River Song reveal, I wasn't really shocked. I mean, in SF movies, everybody is somebody else's surprise father/mother/son/cleaning lady.
I find the River Song concept a bit boring, actually.

But still, I liked the episode, and the hiatus is pretty inconvenient IMO.

As for reinventing the Daleks once again. Yawn!!!!
What are they going to have now? Legs? A trolley cart behind them for their shopping? Didn't they reinvent their look last season already?

[ctc]

>His thinking is that they have lost so many times against the Doctor that if they saw him coming they would be off, they allways lose so there is no suspence in that.

HAW! What's funny about that is: you can actually see that attitude int he show! Hence stuff like the Human Dalek, where they were trying to recreate whatever it is that let's humanity just win all the time.

Don C.

[Mikey]

I just watched it on youtube.

It was ok but it's episodes like this that make me long for the old classic days when stories had no cliffhangers, no story arcs and no purposefully done "epic" feel.

[johnmiic]

Moffatt discussed in Doctor Who Magazine that he wants the show to be on the air more of the year so he is using the summer as a break point where he can introduce an extra cliffhanger. He thought this was good so he can have 1 cliffhanger before the summer and an even bigger finale` in the fall at the end of the season.

I say if you want to have more Doctor Who throughout the year make more episodes per season! Or, since Doctor Who has many Doctors to choose from, why not expand like Law & Order in the US and have new stories for Paul McGann. 1/2 the year for the current Doctor and 1/2 the year for the 8th Doctor. Try it out for a few years.

I loved tonight's episode. Really good.

My only spoiler-don't read it if you don't want to know!!!

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Doctor Who, When A Good Man Goes to War, Season 6, Episode 7:

Daemons run,
when a good man goes to war,
night will fall and drown the sun,
when a good man goes to war,
friendship dies and true love lies,
night will fall and the dark will rise,
when a good man goes to war

[MEMEGO]

P.s. Good episode, liked the Tardis one (The Doctor's Wife) better, but this one ties with it or is slightly below it. What ya all think.

Also, All the hoopla that the USA was finally in syn with the UK, has been dumped out the door for now we are one week behind, NOT BLOODY GOOD MATES!!!!!!!

[MEMEGO]

I read that Moffat said in DrWho Mag, that he will not use the Daleks this year, they will reappear in 2012 with a new look. So thats the official word from him.

Why is the BBC doing a Hiatus for the show? this has never been done, and it is to much of an American thing in my mind. The seaso is to short as it is, maybe if it ran like a regular American show 23 episodes a season, then this would work. As it is I do not like it.(the wait)

[jwyblejr]

It's weird they're taking a break this close to Season 6 Part 1 coming out on DVD.

[StrangeVisitor]

Just finished watching "A Good Man..." on YouTube,

Now, how long is the hiatus supposed to be, I still have questions?!

[wolfie]

Yes Moffat has said he will not use the Daleks again as they have been done to death. His thinking is that they have lost so many times against the Doctor that if they saw him coming they would be off, they allways lose so there is no suspence in that.