The Beatles vs Pink Floyd

[apes3978]

The Beatles Hell I listen to them and Elvis everyday.....lol

Good choices... Okay, I don't go out of my way to listen to the Beatles every day, I usually end up hearing them at some point anyway, be it on SiriusXM or in the car... Presley, I listen to a little bit of "Elvis Radio" every day (even if only during commercial breaks of other shows )

[kingdom warrior]

The Beatles Hell I listen to them and Elvis everyday.....lol

[Toy Timelord]

Just personal preference, but The Beatles.

The Wall is a great album. But even the Beatles humdrum albums were good.

[Nostalgiabuff]

my two all time faves but it would definitely be the Beatles for me. life long and die hard fan. even had Beatles songs for all the big songs at my wedding reception

[TrekStar]

Probably Beatles, but I would be to busy looking for my Maryann.

[Mikey]

I personally think Dark Side and Wish are better than Pepper and Abbey

[EmergencyIan]

Beatles 1000%.


- Ian

[osker55]

Here's a new one - I don't like music. Can I take a book instead?

Really music is the world music is all around you im not a big fan on read but my girl loves to read

[silveralex]

Beatles all the way (but my guitar avatar gave it away, didn't it? )

[The Bat]

Is that even a contest?? The Beatles ALL THE WAY!!!!!

[LonnieFisher]

Pink floyd!!!

[Earth 2 Chris]

I'm pretty sure if you were already depressed about being stranded, a good chunk of Floyd would drive you to suicide. It's much more depressing than any Beatles output.

Chris

[Rallygirl]

Here's a new one - I don't like music. Can I take a book instead?

[apes3978]

I'd say The Beatles...

[Hector]

Queen, Rush, and Led Zeppelin...in that order...

But to stay on topic...I love both, but the Beatles would be more of a cheerful experience, especially stranded on a deserted island...unless I had a massive supply of LSD, then Floyd wins, lol. Oh wait, some of the Beatles's stuff is pretty trippy too...oh darn it...I can't choose, lol.

Other excellent match ups between similar bands:

Chicago vs ELO
Fleetwood Mac vs the Steve Miller Band
The Rolling Stones vs the Who
Boston vs Kansas
Van Halen vs Guns N Roses
Elton John vs Billy Joel
Jimmy Hendrix vs Eric Clapton vs Jeff Beck vs Stevie Ray Vaugh vs Joe Satriani vs Jimmy Page, etc...
Heart vs Pat Benatar