If You Could Only Keep One....Superman or Batman?

[LadyZod]

If choosing to keep Superman over Batman is wrong, I don't want to be right.

Supes stays, Batman finds himself on the curb. Sorry Bat-fans.

[YANOULI]

Get rid of Superman.

[samurainoir]

Grant Morrison is one of my favourite writers and it's great to see him penning both Superman and Batman these days. I have to say that I'm actually enjoying All Star Superman much more than his run on Batman (although they are both excellent). All Star Superman just seems to be stuffed full of imagination and innovative ideas.

In terms of putting Superman back into the A-list, I think the creative team of Mark Millar and Bryan Hitch could prove to be magical if they were handed Superman. Millar's Superman Red Son was an excellent compelling take on Superman and Luthor that felt as classic as anything since the Crisis on Infinite Earth reboot and no one does wide screen action like Hitch.

Alternately, I know it will never happen but Alan Moore was born to write the Silver Age Superman. Just look at the two classic stories Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow and For the Man Who Has Everything. Not to mention his loving tribute to the Silver Age Supes using Liefeld's Supreme character.

[jayihdz]

Composite Superman Batman....problem solved...

[The Toyroom]

But how do you like your JSA? With Golden Age Superman or Golden Age Batman?

[Blue Meanie]

Not a really big fan of either Supes or Bats....I am a HUGE fan of the original JSA. If it was up to me Supes and Bats could both be dropped...as long as you don't touch All-Star Comics(Original JSA) then I'm Happy.

[Wolverine1969]

I grew up a Superman fan. After college I started reading Batman more and really developed an appreciation for the character. So much that I consider myself more a Batman fan than Superman. So I would have to go with Batman.

[number 6]

- I think the one thing his comics have consistently lacked for years that the Batman comics have not is decent writing.

Yeah, that's my thing. The core concept of Superman I love.

But after tons of stories about 'what if Superman and Lois were married', 'what if Superman got split 4 ways', 'what if Jimmy Olsen had 2 heads', etc. I have to wonder is that really worth keeping? It's just a bunch of outlandish stuff that in the end 'doesn't count' continuity wise anyway.

Some better writing and yeah, I would probably pick Superman.

[Flynne]

It strikes me that the answers to this question seem to bear a resemblance to "Why do good girls date bad boys?" - When given the choice between the straight laced boy scout - solid, reliable, and guaranteed to meet their needs - or the troubled, brooding bad boy - breaks laws, rides a motorcycle, and emotionally incapable of commitment - so many go girls for the bad boy. Sound familiar? Sure they want marry Superman - eventually - but they also want to date Batman for a while first.

For myself - If I answered this question a decade ago, I would have said keep Batman. However, as I've gotten older, and my outlook has been irrevocably altered by world events, I've developed a new appreciation for Superman and how much it would mean to the World to really have someone like him, and how much someone would have to sacrifice in order to do it. With regard to the comics being boring or the character of Superman being one dimensional - I think the one thing his comics have consistently lacked for years that the Batman comics have not is decent writing.

The World has scores of vigilantes, but it really needs the Big Blue Boy Scout. Keep Superman.

[number 6]

I'd hate to see either go.

But if I was pushed, I'd have to say Superman.

I love Superman in theory. I really enjoyed Alex Ross's treatment of him in Kingdom Come.

But the vast majority of Superman stories aren't like that. And I find I just don't enjoy them as much as Batman.

[Surfsup]

Definately Superman, the character is boring and for the life of me, I can't see why he's so popular.

Batman on the other hand has an edge and has a far more interesting set up and character's. The villains alone are some of the most colourful ever created.

[Megotu]

Well...If I actually lived in a city protected by either one of them, I would pick Superman as the keeper. I would not live in Gotham. No way. Nuh-uh.
You could NEVER drink the water. You couldn't even shower with it. Even the underarm deodorant has been weaponized.
screw that.

[The Toyroom]

I thought that the Crimson Avenger was the first, Superman only leant the genre his name.

Nope, Crimson Avenger first appeared in Detective Comics #20 (October 1938). Superman already had debuted in Action #1 (June 1938). Crimson Avenger beats Batman though by 7 issues.

[Goblin19]

Ugh, that's hard. My favorite boyhood superhero (Supes) or my favorite from my twenties (Bats). I think Superman has to stay, though I might change my mind. Thank god, you didn't throw Spidey in to the mix.

[SlipperyLilSuckers]

Bye Batman

Superman (and Supergirl) will be my number one til the day I die. I am not getting this tattoo removed.