This just seems like a cash grab byt the studio. Is there seriously that much more to tell about Bilbo after 2 movies?
This just seems like a cash grab byt the studio. Is there seriously that much more to tell about Bilbo after 2 movies?
Mortui Vivos Docent
The Dead Teach the Living
I'm with Damien, the more the better. I also agree he will probably use it to flesh out some of the characters from LOTR and give a bit of backstory, probably from the Silmarillion to explain some of what is to come.
There is so much backstory in Tolkiens work. I wish he could have flesh out more than he was able to.
It would be awesome to see something like this on the screen: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tal...d_L%C3%BAthien
This story also plays into the relationship between Aragorn and Arwen.
I would rather see the Hobbit stand alone and not have added material. If you want the extras, read the books.
Maybe in 10 years Peter Jackson will come back and do the Silamarillon as a trilogy too!
"The days have gone down in the West behind the hills into shadow...How did it come to this?"
Being a huge fan of anything Tolkien (I only watched a documentary this evening) any opportunity to see something more from Jackson and his crew and their treatment of the professor's work will be met with great anticipation by myself. I hope that more material from Middle Earth can somehow be incorporated in the last film. I appreciate the fact that an adaptation will have to take some license with the original literature, and I loved the films. However, part of me feels guilty somehow at the idea that Tolkien himself would be somehow overwhelmed with what his idea has become. I was always a huuuuuge fan of the Rankin Bass animated film (my 7 year old daughter can sing all the songs). I wvwn found a double LP and illustrated book on ebay in immaculate condition which I treasure. So . . I am wracked with guilt about Tolkien's work being in film again and how he would perceive such things and my great desire to return to Middle Earth again where I have spent so many happy years.
I could barely stay awake watching the LOTR trilogy (watched each film once, and that's it).
Now I have to sit through a Hobbit trilogy?
Perhaps when it comes on Blu-ray...but you are not going to watch me sitting next to "Ring" geeks at a public movie theater...no...this geek will sit besides Superhero and Star Trek geeks...but not Ring geeks...
![]()
I can't wait to see this movie. I'm excited about the possibilities.
Sammy