So I did a buy it now on this auction:
Captain Action CAPTAIN AMERICA AQUAMAN costume figures! - eBay (item 260239571466 end time May-14-08 1454 PDT)
Which I thought was a pretty good price for everything I was getting. I had a Captain Action Aquaman suit, so getting the mask and the Captain America suit and mask and the figures was a pretty good deal for me.
When I get the items in, not only did the seller send along another pair of Captain America boots, he included the COMPLETE DC DIRECT AQUAMAN FIGURE, WITH BOX!!! At first I thought it was mistake, so I contacted him to see if he wanted me to send the Aquaman back. He told me no, he had no use for it, and thought I might. Well since I already had that particular Aquaman, I gave it to my son.
We have so many ebay horror stories here, I thought I'd share a nice one.
So thanks 8411mark!!!