With limited chioces Best / Worst films

[Brue]

Pick your #1 (2 points) and your number 2 (1 point) or top two tie (1.5 points each) from these:

1 Superman: The Motion Picture
2 Batman Begins
3 Spider-man
4 X2
5 Superman II
6 Spider-man 2

Pick the worst (2 points) or pick a tie (1 point each)
1 Hulk
2 Batman & Robin
3 Catwoman
4 Superman IV


NOTE: only choose from the lists above.
I will tabulate the winners and loses after a few days and posts are not active.

[joshvox]

hmm...
#1 is no contest, no matter what you put up its Batman Begins. #2 I'd have to say Superman the Motion Picture.

For the worst, #1 Batman and Robin, #2 Catwoman.

[Brue]

I forgat to post my own votes.

best Spider-man, second Superman II

All 6 are GREAT so this was a hard choice.

worst Catwoman may actually be the worst but because of budgets and expectations I am giving the nod to Batman and Robin

Again all 4 of these are terrible so it was a hard choice.

[The Bat]

Best: BATMAN BEGINS!
X-Men 2

Worst: Catwoman
Batman & Robin

[thunderbolt]

Best: Batman Begins and Spidey in that order
worst Batman and Robin and Superman 4 in that order.

[Meule]

Best: Batman Begins followed by Superman
Worst: Hulk, then Batman and Robin

[Hulk]

#1 -Superman: The Motion Picture
#2 Tie - Batman Begins & Spider-man

Worst - Catwoman

[Brue]

So, I was thinking (sometimes i do) and realized I own 3 of the worst on DVD on the 4th on vhs..

Is it our resposibility or curse to need to own thes things as true superhero fans?

[huedell]

So, I was thinking (sometimes i do) and realized I own 3 of the worst on DVD on the 4th on vhs..

Is it our resposibility or curse to need to own thes things as true superhero fans?

Here's the thing regarding those 4 worst listed...

I don't know about Catwoman cause I never saw it

But I will say here's one thing Batman & Robin and Superman IV have that
Hulk doesn't....alotta costume time (including costumed villains),
and goofy humor that can at least occupy the easily "camped" side of our
brains...Hulk is just real dry and only the desert stuff at the end really takes advantage of the "costumed" character

And I STILL own Hulk on DVD

It just may be that "curse" you speak of cause I sure as heck don't feel a
responsibility

I thought Hulk would grow on me to at least being able to watch more than a
few times in vain without being disappointed-------it hasn't

[Brue]

Here's the thing regarding those 4 worst listed...

.. here's one thing Batman & Robin and Superman IV have that
Hulk doesn't....alotta costume time (including costumed villains),
and goofy humor that can at least occupy the easily "camped" side of our
brains...

Yep my fourth grade classes LOVE Batman and Robin because of costumes, multiple characters, action, etc and they just don't get too concerned about with plot, dialogue, faithfulness etc. For most 10 and unders I talk to (including my daughter) B&R id the best Batman.